Read from Saturday, December 18th to Wednesday, December 22nd.
Water for Elephants, by Sara Gruen. This book has been a bestseller in recent years, which attracted my attention. Not until after I finished reading did I discover that it is being made into a major motion picture. It was a good book, one which I read very quickly, but I found that I liked it more for the plot than the style.
It is an historical novel, set in 1931, right in the middle of the Depression. Jacob Jankowski is a veterinary student at Cornell when he learns his parents were killed in a car wreck. They left him with no money, so he was unable to stay at school. So Jacob ran away and hopped on a train, only later to discover that it was a circus train, the Benzini Brothers Circus. Since he had vet training, Jacob was hired by the owner, Uncle Al, to work with the animals. The animal director was named August, and his wife was Marlena, a performer with the horses. Jacob entered into an uneasy relationship with the couple. He quickly fell in love with Marlena, but August was his boss and could be very temperamental. He brutally beat many of the animals, including a new elephant named Rosie who refuses to do any tricks.
Jacob is more loving of the animals, and he soon fits in with the circus. He discovers that Rosie only understands Polish, so he teaches August some Polish phrases, and Rosie is a big success in the show. However, August becomes paranoid of Marlena and Jacob, and he brutally beats both of them one night. Jacob and Marlena vow to leave, but it is not that easy. Uncle Al is greedy and won’t lose his performers, and he has thugs that threaten to throw off the train some of Jacob’s friends if Marlena and August don’t get back together.
Jacob tries to kill August in his sleep, but he backs out. He returns only to find out that he was arranged to be killed and only missed it because he was with August. The next day, disgruntled workers let loose all the animals from the show, causing a riot and stampede. Rosie the elephant kills August, and the workers kill Uncle Al. The show is over, and Jacob and Marlena and Rosie and other animals go off to join Ringling brothers.
The book is narrated from the point of view of Jacob as an old man in a nursing home. His kids have left him alone, and Marlena has already died. He feels no one respects him, except a friendly nurse named Rosemary. When the circus comes to town, none of Jacob’s children arrive to take him, so he sneaks off on his own to watch the show. He meets the show’s manager and tells him his life story. Then Jacob begs to be taken with them, to work as a ticket taker or anything, and the manager, touched by his story, accepts. For the second time in his life, Jacob has run away to join the circus.
It is a fascinating story about the life of a circus worker in that era, and it is accompanied by many interesting photos. Filled with lions, tigers, bears, fat ladies, bearded ladies, trapeze artists, elephants and even prostitution. In terms of plot, it was great, and had me hooked, but I thought the style was a little off. The dialogue felt stilted and fake at times, and a little too clichéd. The characters were often very one-dimensional. Camel got annoying because all he talked about was drinking. Even Jacob was too much of a hero, stubbornly refusing to do anything but the right thing, and him and Marlena falling so deeply in love was almost too easy. Also, the ending felt like a deus ex machina, with everything being resolved so easily. August was killed, Uncle Al killed, and the money problems disappeared as well
But I did enjoy the book, and I am excited for the movie as well. It looks visually very exciting, as the book appeared in my mind. Robert Pattinson plays Jacob and Reese Witherspoon is Marlena. Three and a half out of five stars.